May is the month of High School graduations in the United States. All around me that is all I heard for a few weeks in May. Such joy and relief in the voices of 12th graders who are finishing up school and their parents. A graduation ceremony complete with a cap and gown! Followed by graduation parties with graduation cakes hosted by their families, graduation dinners, the whole nine yards before they start prepping for the college that they have already chosen or the college that has chosen them. I couldn't help but start thinking of my own son's turn in a few years and wondered where his party should be hosted and who to invite. As I pondered on those, I thought of my own 'graduating' from 12th grade in India and how different passing out of 12th grade was perceived back then. What kind of a High school graduation did we have in India? A cap and a gown, a walk to get our diploma? A party? Ours was completely different.
I graduated high school about 25 years ago
under tremendous stress . Stress towards finishing strong and scoring the magic
number which was going to determine which line of specialty I was going to go
in my life. Well, that kind of pressure really starts in tenth grade as we look
upon the public exams! The '10th grade public exam score' paves way to where
you are going-Science or Math or Economics or Commerce. Then the '12th grade
public exam scores' seal the deal for you. Between the exams and the results,
we were enrolled in medical college coaching classes, to prepare for the
entrance exams. Everyone involved had
their tunnel vision glasses and worked with a focus. The 12th grade results
pretty much determines what you will eventually major in. I have never heard of
anyone being able to change their major midway, like in the US. For those who
were successful in acquiring a seat in a medical college, their future was
clear. They were becoming doctors! For those who did not, we moved on, dusted
off the disappointment and enrolled in Arts and Sciences and graduated after 6
six years with a Master's degree. There were plenty of options and we all
succeeded in different areas in the end. But we all started off vying for a medical
seat or an Engineering seat. I do not know why. Looking back,I wished I had
never tried to become a doctor. The dream of becoming one was fascinating but
the grueling process of studying for and writing entrance exams and being
turned down only proved that that cake was not mine to eat. Sure, I am all for
Grey's anatomy and its doctors but I have never envied their jobs or their
lives.
25 years later,
from the news I get from India, nothing much has changed. More stress, more
pressure to perform better, score better, get into that Medical/Engineering
college. I find it interesting to see parents my age, who underwent such
pressure and stress themselves would willingly subject their own children to
this again. And yet they do. As our children battle it out to get the best scores-
to win among the highest scoring children- to the quota systems- to battling
the courts to relax NEET requirements......what is it that makes us be this
way? To impose such high standards on our children that they risk cracking
under pressure. Is our greatest wish to do the best for our children ...more a
vicarious attempt at realizing our failed dreams? Sure, it is a competitive world out there, I
get it. But at what cost do we keep pushing our children? In the end, a handful
get selected, and a bunch get rejected......and chided(for not getting
selected).
How would it be
if we just threw them a party at the end of their 12th grade and called it a
Higher Secondary school graduation? Invite all your extended family so they can
congratulate your kids for the 12 years of hard work and diligence. How about
we do not make them feel like failures for not making the cut that last year
of Higher Secondary school. How about we
tell them there is so much more to life than Medical college or Engineering
College? How about we tell them, "we did not make it into Medical or
Engineering college, it is ok if you did not, either. You can still major in
something else and be happy like we are with our choices". After all,
there are enough doctors and engineers in this world to take care of us.It's
time we took care of our own.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteWe were expecting to coach Ethan for a medical seat in India! I'm just kidding!
ReplyDeleteYes. You are right. There is more to life than getting into a professional college. We are so poor in celebrating. we have to learn to celebrate our children's lives. Thanks.